NYX Professional Makeup

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner Review

Matte black liquid eyeliner with a precision brush tip, marketed as waterproof and vegan with up to 24 hours of wear.

Category Makeup Updated Nov 9, 2026
Check Price on Amazon

Price and availability may change. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner Review

Quick Verdict

A precise, deep-black liquid liner that rewards a steady hand. The NYX Epic Ink Liner is a matte black liquid eyeliner with a brush tip that lets you vary the thickness of the line. It is marketed as waterproof with up to 24 hours of wear and as vegan. Customer feedback is mixed on how waterproof it really is, so expect strong everyday wear and plan for oily lids and tears.

Liquid eyeliner is the product that separates quick makeup from precise makeup. A single line can lift the eye, define the lash line and create a wing. The NYX Epic Ink Liner is one of the best-known drugstore liquid liners, and its popularity comes from a combination of intensity, precision and price.

This review draws on the brand’s product information, retailer listings and customer feedback patterns. We have not tested NYX Epic Ink Liner ourselves. We separate claims from evidence and from opinion.

What Is the NYX Epic Ink Liner?

The NYX Epic Ink Liner is a liquid eyeliner pen with a brush tip. The Amazon listings describe a waterproof matte liquid eyeliner for cat-eye looks, with a tip that adjusts the line thickness by pressure, a vegan and cruelty-free formula and up to 24 hours of wear. The main listing is for the black shade. Other colours, glitter versions, retractable pencils and bundles also appear.

The listing’s review summary notes that many customers praise the wear, while a large share say it is not truly waterproof. We take that into account in this review.

Woman in baby blue knit polo holding NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
AI-generated illustration for this review. It is not a photo from a hands-on test.

Key Features

  • Matte black liquid eyeliner
  • Brush tip adjustable by pressure
  • Marketed as waterproof, with up to 24 hours of wear
  • Vegan and cruelty-free, per the listing
  • Black shade used for this listing
  • Many other shades and glitter versions sold

What It Is Designed For

The liner is designed for defined, graphic lines, such as a thin line along the lash line or a winged cat-eye. The brush tip lets you draw thin lines with light pressure and thicker lines with more pressure. The matte black finish is deep and flat, without shine.

It is not designed for smudged, smoky looks. For that, a pencil or gel liner is easier to work with.

Liquid, Gel, Pencil and Pen Eyeliners

Liquid liners deliver the sharpest line and the most intense colour, but they take practice and can transfer. Gel liners, applied with a brush, are forgiving and long-lasting. Pencils are easy to use and good for smudged looks, and waterline use needs a pencil formulated for it. Felt-tip pens are easy to control but can dry out.

A liquid pen with a brush tip sits between a classic liquid and a felt tip. It is easier than a pot of liquid and more flexible than a felt tip. If you are new to liquid liner, practise on the back of your hand and start with a thin line.

How to Apply a Liquid Liner

Rest your elbow on a table and keep your eye relaxed. Look slightly downward into a mirror, and draw the line in small strokes from the inner to the outer corner, building it instead of drawing one long line. For a wing, extend the line upward and outward, following the lower lash line, and connect it back to the lid.

Let NYX Epic Ink Liner dry for a few seconds before opening your eyes fully to avoid transfer to the upper lid. Clean up mistakes with a cotton swab dipped in remover. Our guide to mascara smudging under the eyes covers keeping eye makeup in place.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Deep black payoff with a matte finish
  • Precise tip for thin lines and wings
  • Affordable and widely available
  • Many other colours in the range

Cons

  • Waterproof claim is disputed in customer feedback
  • Can smudge on oily lids
  • Liquid liners take practice

Who Should Buy It?

Buy the NYX Epic Ink Liner if you like defined, graphic eyes, if you are comfortable with liquid liner, and if you want a deep black line at a low price. It suits people who wear eye makeup regularly and want a precise tool for wings and thin lines.

Who Should Skip It?

Skip it if you are new to eye makeup and want a forgiving pencil, if you have very oily lids that transfer makeup or if you need a guaranteed waterproof product for swimming or crying. People with sensitive eyes should be careful with any eyeliner. For a pencil that can fill and define the brows, the NYX Micro Brow Pencil is a different kind of precision tool.

Price and Value

We do not quote prices because they change. The button on this page opens the Amazon listing. In general, this liner is a drugstore product, and a single pen lasts for months with regular use. Liquid liners should be replaced every three to six months because they dry out and collect bacteria.

Check the shade and pack. Amazon lists black, brown and glitter versions, plus bundles with lip liners.

Making Liquid Liner Last

Prime the lid with a light eyeshadow primer or a dab of concealer set with powder, which gives the liner something to grip. Let your eye cream and moisturizer absorb fully before makeup. Avoid applying liner over greasy products.

Set the line with a matching eyeshadow pressed on top if you want extra staying power, and avoid touching your eyes. If your lids are very oily, a primer designed for eyelids helps. For related base steps, our review of the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer covers a face primer that some people also use on the lids.

Common Mistakes With Liquid Liner

The most common mistake is drawing one long line instead of short strokes. The second is applying too thick a line at the inner corner. The third is not letting it dry. The fourth is applying over oily skin.

Another is keeping an old liner. Liquid liners dry out and can irritate eyes, so replace them every few months and never use one during an eye infection.

Safety and When to See a Doctor

Eye products should be used carefully, and removed every night. If you notice redness, swelling, discharge or pain, stop using eye makeup and see a doctor. Never share eyeliner.

Use an eye makeup remover or an oil cleanser for waterproof formulas, and avoid rubbing. Gentle removal protects the lashes and the delicate skin around the eyes.

Drawing a Wing in Three Steps

Start by drawing a small line from the outer corner of the eye, extending outward and slightly upward along the line of the lower lash line. Next, draw a line from the end of the wing back toward the middle of the upper lid. Finally, fill in the space between the lines and connect the wing to the lash line.

Practise with a small wing and increase the length as your confidence grows. Some people use tape or a card as a guide, though a steady hand and short strokes work as well. If a wing comes out uneven, use a cotton swab with a little remover to sharpen the edge.

Eyeliner Shapes for Different Eyes

For hooded eyes, draw the line with your eyes open so you can see how it appears. For round eyes, a wing elongates the shape. For close-set eyes, start the line slightly after the inner corner. For downturned eyes, lift the wing upward.

These are only guidelines. Use what you like, and keep the line thin if you are unsure, because it is easier to add than to remove.

Eyeliner and Eye Health

The inner rim of the eye, called the waterline, is delicate, and applying liner there can introduce bacteria and block oil glands. Many eye doctors suggest keeping liner on the outside of the lash line and using products designed for the waterline only when necessary.

Replace liners regularly, avoid sharing and remove eye makeup nightly. If you wear contact lenses, insert them before makeup and remove them before removing makeup.

Colour Choices Beyond Black

Black is the classic choice, but brown can look softer and more natural, particularly on lighter skin and eyes. Colours such as navy, green and burgundy can brighten certain eye colours: navy flatters brown eyes, green flatters hazel and burgundy flatters green and blue.

The line includes other colours and glitter versions. Starting with brown or black gives you the most versatility, and a coloured liner can be a fun addition once you are comfortable with the technique.

Removing Waterproof Liner Safely

Waterproof liners need an oil-based or dedicated eye makeup remover. Press a soaked pad against the eye for several seconds to dissolve the product, then wipe gently from the inner to the outer corner. Repeat with a clean pad until it comes away clean.

Avoid dragging the lid or rubbing, which can irritate the skin and pull out lashes. Follow with a gentle cleanser to remove oil residue. If your eyes feel sore or look red after removal, give them a rest from eye makeup and see a doctor if symptoms persist.

Keeping Liquid Liner Fresh

Store the pen horizontally or tip-down so the ink flows to the tip. Close the cap firmly after use. If the tip frays, replace the pen, because a damaged tip draws shaky lines.

Wipe the tip with a clean tissue after use, and do not dip it into water or remover. Replace the liner every three to six months, and sooner after any eye infection. A fresh pen makes a more noticeable difference to results than most techniques.

Eyeliner and Hooded or Sensitive Eyes

Hooded eyelids can hide a line drawn with the eyes closed. Draw the line with your eyes open and looking straight ahead in the mirror, and adjust the thickness to what shows. Thin lines and small wings often suit hooded eyes better than thick ones.

If your eyes are sensitive or water easily, choose a product tested for sensitive eyes, apply the line away from the waterline and take breaks. Liquid liner can irritate some people, and if your eyes become red or itchy, stop using it and see a doctor.

Checklist Before You Buy

Before ordering the NYX Epic Ink Liner, check the shade, the pack size and whether you are buying the liquid pen or one of the retractable pencils in the same range. If you are new to liquid liner, read customer comments about waterproof performance and keep a good eye makeup remover at hand.

Alternatives

For a mascara with a lifting brush, the Maybelline Falsies Lash Lift Washable Mascara complements a liner. For a drama-focused mascara, the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High is popular. For brows to frame the look, the NYX Micro Brow Pencil is the natural companion.

What other testers and reviewers report

This section summarises what other people have published about the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner. These are their findings, not a BeautyFinderr test, and we have not used the product ourselves. Both sources are single-person reviews with affiliate links, not controlled tests. Sources were read in November 2026; check each page for the latest version.

Well+Good, via theSkimm (January 2023). In a liquid eyeliner roundup, authors Alexa Casanova and Clare Holden wore over a dozen liners, including at a humid wedding, and named this the best waterproof liquid liner. They describe a fast-drying formula with a precise brush tip, strong pigment often in one swipe, an affordable price and a beginner-friendly feel, pitched as a cheaper alternative to a more expensive tattoo liner. The cons were that it needs a primer on hot, humid days and that the brush tip can fray if handled carelessly. No test length is given for this liner.

BuzzFeed (updated May 2019). Writer Sarah Han used it for about a year and reports a very dark, one-swipe line with a soft brush that pulls less on the lid, no smudging or shifting through the day, a pen that had not dried out after a year, and line thickness adjustable by pressure. She notes it looks wet and shiny for a few seconds until it dries, like any liquid liner takes some practice, and carries a six-month expiry on the label. This is an older post.

What this adds up to. Both found a precise, strongly pigmented liner that holds up well, and the main caveats are the drying time and the practice needed. We found no independent lab test.

FAQ

Is the NYX Epic Ink Liner waterproof?
It is marketed as waterproof, but customer feedback is mixed.

How long does it last?
The brand claims up to 24 hours, though real wear depends on your skin and conditions.

Is it vegan?
The listing describes it as vegan and cruelty-free.

Is it easy for beginners?
Liquid liner takes practice, and a pencil is more forgiving.

How do I remove it?
With an eye makeup remover or an oil cleanser, applied gently.

Final Verdict

The NYX Epic Ink Liner is a deep, precise liquid liner that suits people who like defined eyes. The brush tip is versatile, the colour is intense and the price is low. It takes practice, it can smudge on oily lids and its waterproof claim should be taken with caution. For anyone who wants a graphic line without paying much, it is a good option to learn with.

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
Where to buy

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner

Matte black liquid eyeliner with a precision brush tip, marketed as waterproof and vegan with up to 24 hours of wear.

Check Price on Amazon

Price and availability may change. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Scroll to Top