Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara Review
The classic pink-and-green drugstore mascara in a washable formula, claimed to double lashes and condition as it thickens, in Blackest Black.
Price and availability may change. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Verdict
A budget mascara classic that prioritizes comfort and easy removal over drama. Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is a long-running drugstore formula that builds natural-looking volume and removes with warm water and soap. It suits sensitive eyes and everyday wear. If you want waterproof, lifted, dramatic lashes, a different mascara will serve you better.
Few cosmetics have a more recognizable package than a pink tube with a green cap. Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara has been on drugstore shelves for decades, and it keeps selling because it does a modest job reliably and costs very little.
In a market of long-wear, lash-lift and serum-infused mascaras, a simple washable formula can feel old-fashioned. It can also be exactly what a sensitive-eyed, low-maintenance mascara wearer wants. This review looks at the formula, who it fits and where it stops.
This review is based on the brand’s product information, retailer listings and general patterns in customer feedback. We have not tested the product ourselves, and we mark clearly where something is a brand claim rather than an independent finding.
What Is the Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara?
Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is a classic mascara in the brand’s pink and green tube. The Amazon listing describes a volumizing, lash-doubling formula that conditions as it thickens, and retailer copy says it is ophthalmologist tested, hypoallergenic tested and safe for contact lens wearers. The most common listing is Blackest Black in a 0.43 fl oz tube.
The Great Lash name covers several products, including a Lots of Lashes version and a Big version. Amazon also sells multi-packs. Check the title for “Washable” and the pack size before ordering, and note that some third-party pages flag older listings as discontinued, so confirm availability on the live page.
Key Features
- Washable lash-doubling formula, per the Amazon listing
- Conditions as it thickens, according to the brand
- Ophthalmologist tested, hypoallergenic tested and contact lens safe, per retailer copy
- Blackest Black shade is the most common listing
- 0.43 fl oz tube
- Easy to remove with warm water or micellar water
What It Is Designed For
The mascara is designed to add natural-looking thickness and definition for everyday wear. The washable formula means you can remove it with warm water and a gentle cleanser, which makes it practical for people who dislike scrubbing or who find waterproof remover irritating. It is not designed to hold a curl for twelve hours or to survive a swim.
Think of it as an easy, comfortable mascara for daily use, with a result that looks like your lashes, only fuller.
What Washable Means in Practice
Washable mascaras are water-soluble, so they dissolve with warm water and mild cleanser. The benefit is comfort and easy removal. The trade-off is that moisture can break the film down, which means smudging under humid conditions or if your eyes water. Many people with oily lids also notice transfer onto the upper eyelid by afternoon. If that sounds like you, set the lid area with a bit of powder, or look at our guide on why mascara smudges under the eyes.
Volume, Length and the Classic Brush
Great Lash is a volumizing formula, so expect a thicker, darker lash line and more modest length. The brush is a classic style that coats from root to tip and lets you build layers. Apply a first coat, wiggle the brush at the base of the lashes, then add a second coat while the first is still tacky, and comb through before it dries to avoid clumps. If you want lift and separation, a lash-lift formula like the Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift is a closer match.
Sensitive Eyes and Contact Lenses
Retailer copy states that the mascara is hypoallergenic tested and contact lens safe, which is why it is often recommended for sensitive eyes. That is a marketing statement, not a guarantee, and anyone can react to any product. If your eyes burn, water or swell, stop using it and speak to an eye professional. Replace mascara every three months, because bacteria build up inside the tube, and never share it.
How It Compares to Other Drugstore Mascaras
Drugstore shelves are crowded. Sky High aims for length and flexible lashes, and our Maybelline Sky High review covers that. L’Oréal’s Voluminous Lash Paradise leans toward big volume, and Telescopic targets length, as discussed in our Lash Paradise review. Great Lash is the simple one: natural, washable, uncomplicated. That clarity helps you decide whether it suits your habits.
A Short History of a Drugstore Icon
The pink-and-green tube has been a fixture of drugstore shelves for a very long time, and the formula has been refreshed several times over the years. Longevity in cosmetics usually means a product has solved a real problem: in this case, giving people a comfortable, natural mascara that does not need a special remover. It is a reminder that trends in lash products, from fibers to lifting wands, have not replaced the appeal of something simple.
Oily Lids, Humidity and Smudging
Washable mascara works with water, which means oil and moisture can work against it. If you have oily eyelids, expect some transfer under the lower lash line and on the lid crease by late in the day. A few things help: use an eye primer or a dab of concealer set with powder on the lids, apply the mascara to the lashes only and avoid touching the lower lid, and let each coat dry before the next. If you need the look to last through sweat or tears, a waterproof formula is the right tool, and its removal needs a proper remover.
Building a Natural Lash Look
For an everyday look, curl, apply two coats of Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara and comb through. For more definition, add a second thin coat to the outer corners only. For a softer look, apply it only to the top lashes and use a brown or soft black shade if available. Pair it with simple brows and a light base, such as the Maybelline Fit Me foundation, for a clean, natural makeup look.
Mascara Hygiene and Shelf Life
Mascara is one of the cosmetics most likely to harbor bacteria, because the tube is damp and the wand touches your eyes. Replace it every three months, discard it after an eye infection and never add water or saliva to revive it. Keep it away from heat, which can thicken the formula, and wipe the wand before you put it back in the tube. A cheap mascara that you replace regularly is safer than an expensive one you keep for a year.
Choosing the Right Shade and Pack
The common listing is Blackest Black, but Amazon also sells other shades and multi-packs. Brown-black or brown can look softer on light lashes and eyes. If you are tempted by a large multi-pack, remember the three-month rule. Because older listings can be flagged as discontinued on third-party pages, confirm that the one you choose shows as available and ships from a reputable seller.
How to Use It
Curl your lashes first if you use a curler, then wipe the wand on the tube rim to remove excess. Place the brush at the base of the top lashes, wiggle gently and sweep upward. Apply a second coat before the first dries. For the lower lashes, use only the tip of the wand. Let it dry for a moment before blinking, and remove it at night with warm water and a gentle cleanser or micellar water.
Keep the tube closed tightly, and do not pump the wand in and out, which pushes air in and dries out the formula.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Natural-looking volume that builds in layers
- Washes off without waterproof remover
- Very inexpensive and easy to find
- Gentle option for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Cons
- Not waterproof, so it can smudge in humidity or tears
- Length and curl are modest
- Can clump if you layer without combing
- Listings vary by shade and pack size, and some mirrors flag availability
Who Should Buy It?
Buy Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara if you want a natural look, an easy removal routine and a very low price. It also suits people who wear contact lenses or whose eyes dislike waterproof removers, and anyone who just wants a reliable everyday mascara.
Who Should Skip It?
Skip it if you want long, lifted, curl-holding lashes, if you wear mascara in humid conditions or around water, or if you cry easily at events. For a more dramatic look, consider the essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, and for length the L’Oréal Telescopic is a common pick.
Price and Value
We do not list prices because they change and differ by seller. The button on this page opens the current Amazon listing. This is one of the cheapest well-known mascaras, and multi-packs are common. As with any mascara, the tube has a short shelf life, so a multi-pack is only a saving if you will use each tube within a few months.
Common Mistakes
The first mistake is pumping the wand, which dries out the mascara. The second is using it past three months. The third is layering many coats without combing, which causes clumps. Another is expecting waterproof performance from a washable formula, and then blaming the product for smudging in the rain.
Finally, avoid pulling the lashes when you remove it. Let the warm water and cleanser loosen the formula first.
Safety and When to See a Professional
Eye products carry special risks. Do not use mascara if you have an eye infection, and discard any tube you used during one. Stop using it if you experience redness, burning, swelling or discharge, and see a doctor if symptoms continue. Never apply mascara while driving or in a moving vehicle, and do not share it with others.
Alternatives
For length and flex, see the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High. For a bigger, more dramatic volume, the L’Oréal Voluminous Lash Paradise is the comparison. For a lifted look with a washable formula, try the Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Washable Mascara.
FAQ
Is Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara waterproof?
No. The washable formula rinses off with warm water and soap, and it can smudge with moisture.
Is it safe for contact lens wearers?
Retailer copy says it is contact lens safe and ophthalmologist tested. Stop use if your eyes react.
How do I remove it?
Warm water and a gentle cleanser or micellar water usually work.
Does it make lashes longer?
It is mainly volumizing. Length is modest compared with lengthening mascaras.
How long does a tube last?
Replace mascara about every three months.
Final Verdict
Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is the sensible, unfussy choice in a crowded category. It builds natural volume, removes easily and costs little, and its softness is the whole point. If you want drama, lift or waterproof wear, look elsewhere. If you want a dependable everyday mascara that behaves, this classic still earns its place in the makeup bag.