NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss Review

Quick Verdict

Lip gloss has had a major comeback, and Butter Gloss has been a steady favourite through every trend cycle. Its reputation rests on one thing above all: it is comfortable. Many glosses feel sticky or thick, while Butter Gloss is designed to feel creamy and soft. In this review we look at what the formula offers, how to wear it, how to make it last longer and who should pick something else.

This review is based on NYX Professional Makeup’s product information, current retailer listings and the general pattern of customer feedback. We have not tested it ourselves, and we separate documented facts from editorial opinion throughout.

What Is NYX Butter Gloss?

Butter Gloss is a lip gloss with a doe-foot applicator and a creamy, buttery texture. NYX describes it as non-sticky, with sheer to medium buildable colour and a glossy, shiny finish. It comes in a wide range of shades, many named after desserts, ranging from clear and soft nudes to pinks, corals and deeper berry tones.

Many customers also mention a sweet scent. If you are sensitive to fragrance, check the current ingredient list before buying.

Key Features

• Creamy, buttery texture
• Non-sticky feel
• Sheer to medium buildable colour
• Glossy, shiny finish
• Doe-foot applicator
• Wide range of shades

What It Is Designed For

NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss is designed for everyday lip colour that feels comfortable and looks fresh. It suits quick makeup routines, natural looks and anyone who finds matte lipsticks too drying. It can also be layered over lipstick or lip liner to add shine and dimension.

How to Wear It

For a sheer, natural look, apply one layer straight from the applicator, starting in the centre of the lips and blending outwards. For more colour, add a second layer. Because the formula is creamy, a small amount goes a long way; too much gloss can slide past the lip line.

For a fuller, more defined look, line the lips first with a liner close to your natural lip colour, fill them in lightly with the liner, then apply Butter Gloss on top. The liner gives shape and helps the colour last a little longer, while the gloss adds shine.

Layering Over Lipstick

A popular way to use a gloss is on top of another lip product. Over a matte liquid lipstick, it adds a glossy finish and makes the lips feel more comfortable, though the gloss itself will transfer. Over a creamy bullet lipstick, it softens the colour and adds dimension. A clear or sheer nude Butter Gloss shade is the most versatile option for layering because it adds shine without changing the colour underneath.

Making Gloss Last Longer

Gloss naturally wears off faster than lipstick, especially with eating and drinking. A few tricks help. Exfoliate dry lips gently before applying, since flakes make gloss look uneven. Use a lip liner as a base to give the colour something to cling to. Keep the gloss in your bag for quick touch-ups, which only take a few seconds. And accept that part of a gloss’s charm is that it is easy to reapply rather than built to last all day.

Choosing a Shade

Sheer nudes and pinks are the easiest everyday choices and flatter most skin tones. Deeper berries and warm browns give more colour and work well on deeper skin tones and for evening looks. Because the formula is sheer to medium, the colour in the tube will look lighter on the lips, and your natural lip colour will show through, so shades tend to be forgiving.

Pros & Cons

Who Should Buy It?

Buy NYX Butter Gloss if you want a comfortable, everyday lip product, if you find matte lipsticks too drying, or if you like a fresh, glossy finish that is easy to reapply.

Who Should Skip It?

If you need lip colour that lasts through meals and long days, a long-wear formula such as Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink is more suitable. If you are sensitive to fragrance, check the ingredient list first.

Price and Value

We do not quote prices because they change; the button on this page opens the current listing. NYX Butter Gloss is affordable enough that many people own several shades, which makes it easy to match different looks.

Lip Prep for a Smoother Gloss

Gloss sits on the surface of the lips, so the condition of the skin underneath is very visible. Dry flakes catch the product and make it look uneven. Once or twice a week, gently buff the lips with a soft, damp washcloth or a lip scrub, then apply a nourishing balm. On the day, blot away any excess balm before applying Butter Gloss so it does not slide.

At night, a thicker layer of balm helps keep lips soft, which makes any lip product look better the next morning.

Common Mistakes

The most common mistake is applying too much gloss at once, which leads to product pooling at the corners of the mouth and bleeding past the lip line. One thin layer, applied from the centre outwards, usually looks better. The second is pairing a very sheer gloss with a heavily lined lip in a much darker shade; as the gloss wears, the liner becomes the most visible part. Choosing a liner close to your natural lip colour avoids that.

Finally, remember that doe-foot applicators touch the lips directly. Avoid sharing glosses, and replace a tube if it starts to smell different or the texture changes.

An Everyday Lip Routine

A simple routine is balm in the morning, blotted off before makeup, then one layer of Butter Gloss. Reapply after meals, and finish the day with balm again. It is easy and comfortable.

Alternatives

For long-wear matte colour, try Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick. For a coordinated flush on the cheeks, the e.l.f. Putty Blush pairs naturally with a soft gloss.

FAQ

Is NYX Butter Gloss sticky?
It is designed to be non-sticky, with a creamy feel.

How much colour does it give?
Sheer to medium, and buildable with a second layer.

Does it have a scent?
Many customers mention a sweet scent; check the ingredient list if you are sensitive.

Can I wear it over lipstick?
Yes, it is often layered over lipstick or liner.

How long does it last?
Like most glosses, it needs reapplying after eating and drinking.

Is it good for dry lips?
It is more comfortable than matte formulas, but exfoliating and using balm helps.

Final Verdict

NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss is an easy, affordable favourite for comfortable, glossy lips. It will not last like a liquid lipstick, and it is not meant to, but for everyday shine and soft colour, it is one of the most pleasant glosses to wear.